How to Create a Successful Index in Your Commonplace Book – Make it functional, searchable, and fun to use

So you’ve started your commonplace book — that brilliant archive of quotes, ideas, reflections, and knowledge — but now you’re wondering:

“How will I ever find anything again?”

Enter: the index. Not the boring kind from textbooks — but a living, creative tool that helps you track, retrieve, and connect what matters most to you.

In this post, you’ll learn how to create an index that actually works, using colors, symbols, and smart categorisation.

🧭 Why an Index Matters

A commonplace book isn’t just about collecting ideas — it’s about returning to them later. A good index helps you:

• Find entries without flipping aimlessly
• Spot patterns and recurring themes
• Make your notebook a long-term reference tool
• Reduce clutter in your mind — because you know where things live

✍️ Step 1: Reserve Index Pages Up Front

When you start your notebook, leave the first 2–4 pages blank for your index (or keep it in the back — some people prefer that).

Number your pages as you go, or choose a notebook with pre-numbered pages.

🗂 Step 2: Choose How You Want to Organize

You can organize your index alphabetically, by category, chronologically, or visually.

A. Alphabetical

Best if your entries are wide-ranging and you want quick lookup by topic or keyword.

Example:

A – Art: 14, 22, 35  
C – Creativity: 8, 41  
P – Philosophy: 3, 19, 56

B. By Category Code or Symbol

Use a short code or icon for each theme.

Example:

💡 Insights: 5, 18, 42  
📚 Book Quotes: 7, 12, 33  
🎯 Life Advice: 2, 9, 47  

C. By Date or Entry Number

This works if your entries are more journal-style. Just add tags or colors to entries and track them.

🎨 Step 3: Add Color Codes

Assign a color to each category. Use highlighters, colored pens, or stickers in both your entries and your index.

Category	Color
Quotes	Orange
Philosophy	Blue
Writing Tips	Green
Creativity	Yellow
Reflection	Purple

In your index, colour in the margin or underline the page number with the corresponding colour. It makes flipping through fast and visual.

✴️ Step 4: Use Symbols for Scan-Ability

Symbols add a quick visual cue for what kind of content is on a page. Use these both in the entry margin and in the index.

Symbol	Meaning
⭐	Favorite quote
💡	Insight
🎯	Actionable idea
🔁	Revisit / reread
✍️	Writing prompt

Example Index Line:

Pg 22 – “Steal Like an Artist” – 💡 🎯 ✍️ (green)

This shows it’s an insight, actionable, and writing-related — all at a glance.

🛠 Bonus: Combine Systems for Maximum Power

The best index systems are personal hybrids. Try mixing:

• Alphabetical structure + colored page numbers
• Category symbols + chronological log
• Abbreviation codes + highlighting

There are no rules. If it works for you, it’s the right system.

📖 Sample Index Entry (All Together)

Pg 12 – “The Obstacle Is the Way” – PHL 💡 🎯 (blue dot)
Pg 27 – “Writing with Clarity” – WRT ✍️ ⭐ (green dot)
Pg 34 – “On Slowing Down” – LIF 🔁 💬 (purple dot)

You can even group entries under section headers like:

Creativity (yellow)

• Pg 5 – “Flow State” 💡
• Pg 18 – “Permission to Make Bad Art” ⭐

✅ Final Tips

• Index as you go along — the system only works if you use it.
• Review your index monthly — you’ll spot patterns and connections.
• Leave room to grow — your categories may evolve as your book fills.

Interested to try Commonplacing?

The Big One is our quarterly journaling subscription, where we take a deeper dive into a self-care, self-development or productivity concept.

For our September 2025 box we will be exploring the concept of Commonplacing in more depth, with a bumper bundle of tools to help you incorporate the method into your journal.

Subscriptions are now open to new subscribers *while stocks last*